Liberal party members who attempted to have white South African farmers singled out for special treatment when applying for asylum in Australia have been defeated after an interjection from Philip Ruddock.

Ruddock pointed out that there are about 65 million people around the world who are displaced, and about  22 million of them refugees.  That is: they are on the move, looking for somewhere safe to live.  He pointed out that we can’t help them all.

That’s true, but it misses the point completely.  First, they aren’t all trying to come to Australia.  boat arrivals in Australia typically tracked parallel with global refugee movement.  Second, no-one is suggesting that we should try to save them all.

When was in Lesbos helping make the film Border Politics, I heard a story, probably a global story which has been embraced by people living on Lesbos.  It went like this:

There is a beach on Lesbos where the full tide sometimes washes up thousands of starfish.  Sometimes, depending on the wind as the tide goes out, the starfish are stranded on the beach and if they stay there they dry out in the sun and die.  A little girl in Lesbos was very distressed by this, and went down to the beach.  A grown-up said to her, very sensibly, “You know, you can’t save all of them”.  Her response: she bent down, picked one up, threw it into the ocean and said “Well, I’ve saved that one!”

If all of us are troubled by the idea that we mistreat boat people who get to Australia, then all of us, together, can make a big difference.

Just try to save one at a time.  Try to save just one.