It is worth looking at the terms of the Memorandum of Understanding between Australia and Papua New Guinea.

It sets the frame-work for the humanitarian horrors which are unfolding there.

Bear in mind: the MOU makes it clear that the purpose of the whole exercise is to combat people smugglers by making an example of the people held on Manus.  When government Ministers say they are worried about people drowning, don’t believe them: they are using the survivors as hostages.

If they were genuinely worried about people drowning, they would treat the survivors decently, but there’s no trace of that: not in the MOU and not in the way it is playing out: inadequate medical care; refugees had to queue 7 hours today to get fed.

Just for a moment, imagine that the refugees held on Manus are German Jews, late 1930s: is our treatment of them ethically acceptable?

Here’s the MOU: notice there is no promise they will be treated decently.